Blog
Welcome to our blog.
Looking for something specific?
Enter your keywords in the searchbar below.
1 minute Martini Manna
UPC, Milan Central Division: limits on the abusive use of divisional applications
By an order of 22 October 2026, issued in proceedings UPC_CFI_2221/2026, brought by Sandoz AG against Novo Nordisk A/S concerning Unitary Patent EP 3 689 365, the Milan Central Division of the Unified Patent Court (UPC), ruling on a preliminary objection to jurisdiction, addressed the use of divisional applications by a patent proprietor seeking to avoid a decision on the validity of its patent while retaining substantially equivalent protection through new applications within the same patent family.
The Court held that its jurisdiction, although confined to the matters listed in Article 32 of the Agreement on a Unified Patent Court (UPCA), encompasses the powers necessary to ensure effective judicial protection, including against the abusive use of divisional applications.
Know-how and collaborations without a contract: lessons from the Court of Bari
Contributing to the development of someone else's product is not enough to claim its know-how. In judgment no. 5270/2026 of 4 November 2026, the Specialised Business Division of the Court of Bari dismissed the claims of a company alleging misappropriation of its technical knowledge under Articles 98 and 99 of the Italian Industrial Property Code (IPC) and Article 2598(3) of the Italian Civil Code.
Thrilling trademarks: Monsterland vs. Horrorland
With an order of October 6th, 2026 (issued in interim proceedings under docket No. 12302/2026), the Court of Bologna dismisses the application brought by the owner of “MONSTERLAND HALLOWEEN FESTIVAL” trademark, who organises the event by the same name, against the organisers of a competing event, for the use of allegedly similar signs, confusing and parasitic unfair competition. According to the Court, the differences between the signs used, together with the weak distinctive character of the earlier trademark, rules out any likelihood of confusion. The Court also excludes parasitic unfair competition, noting that the respondents themselves contributed to organising previous editions of the festival arranged by the applicant.
Copyright protection for industrial design: the Milan Court of Appeal protects Ferrari car designs and seeks to align the artistic value requirement with MIO/USM Haller
Referring to the EU case law in Cofemel and Mio/USM Haller, the Court gave precedence to originality, while considering that artistic value may nevertheless help confirm it ex post, as a result of the work’s subsequent recognition over time as a cultural or social icon.
Westlaw, ROSS and the boundaries of Fair Use: When AI training infringes copyright
In its judgment of the 29th of September 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upholds the first-instance decision in the dispute between Thomson Reuters and ROSS Intelligence. The Court recognises that the editorial annotations (headnotes) published on the Westlaw platform are protected by copyright and holds that their use to train an artificial intelligence system cannot benefit from the fair use exception under the US Copyright Act.
Copyright protection of industrial design works: the Venice Court protects Kartell’s Componibili, but continues to require artistic value
The Court of Venice granted copyright protection to Kartell’s famous “Componibili” modular storage units, designed by Anna Castelli Ferrieri in 1967, and enjoined the marketing of three competing products named “Oasi”, “Mirage” and “Eden”. In doing so, the court assessed both creativity and artistic value, although the latter seems incompatible with the EU law.
Not too hot nor too cold: The EU General Court annuls the EUIPO decision on “MID season” trademark
In its judgment on the 7th of October 2026 (Case T‑9/26), the General Court of the European Union (Seventh Chamber) annulled the decision by which the Second Board of Appeal of EUIPO upheld the rejection of the application for a declaration of invalidity of the figurative trademark “MID season For When It’s Not Quite Cold Not Quite Warm”, registered for leather goods, clothing and the related retail services. The General Court held that the Board had erred in finding that “mid-season” had no specific meaning in the fashion sector capable of rendering the sign devoid of distinctive character. That error tainted the assessment both of the sign’s characters: the descriptive and the distinctive one, in breach of Article 7(1)(c) and (b) of EU Regulation 2017/1001.
Clash of Titans: Freedom of Expression vs. Trade Mark Protection — The IKEA v. Vrijheidsfonds VZW Case
A recent judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (September 8th, 2026, Case C‑298/23) had to balance two conflicting fundamental rights: the right to intellectual property, guaranteed to the proprietor of a notorious trade mark under Article 17(2) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, and freedom of expression, guaranteed by Article 11 of the same Charter.
The So-Called “Ferragni Law” Enters into Force: New Obligations for Products, Advertising and Influencer Marketing Linked to Charitable Initiatives
Law No. 120 of 19 June 2026, containing “Provisions on the Allocation of Proceeds from the Sale of Products”, entered into force on 21 July 2026. The law introduces specific transparency obligations for commercial initiatives in which the sale of a product is linked to the allocation of part of the proceeds to charitable organisations or initiatives.
Data Act and connected products: who can use the data generated by machinery and devices?
Cars, household appliances, medical devices, industrial plants and agricultural machinery continuously generate data during their use. Until recently, however, this information often remained under the exclusive control of the manufacturer or the provider of the related service.
The Data Act, namely Regulation (EU) 2023/2854, introduces new rules aimed at making such data more accessible and usable. The Regulation has applied since 12 September 2025 and affects, among others, manufacturers of connected devices, providers of applications and digital services, and businesses using smart machinery.
ANIMAL FARM and 1984: according to EUIPO, titles of literary works are not registrable as trademarks where the public does not perceive them as indicators of commercial origin
By decision of 27 May 2026, issued in joined cases R 1719/2019-G and R 1922/2019-G, the Grand Board of Appeal of EUIPO confirmed the partial refusal of registration of the signs ANIMAL FARM and 1984, corresponding to the titles of George Orwell's famous novels, in respect of a series of goods and services falling, among others, within Classes 9, 16, and 41 (as well as, for the ANIMAL FARM mark alone, Class 28).
IP preliminary injunctions after the CJEU: does the deadline for bringing proceedings on the merits run while the appeal against the PI is pending?
The Court of Milan clarifies that, where the defendant’s appeal against an IP preliminary injunction is still pending, the deadline to bring proceedings on the merits starts running only after the appeal proceedings have been concluded.
Crocs: the EU General Court confirms the lack of individual character of the famous sandals
With the judgment of 22 April 2026 (caseT-228/25), the General Court of the European Union confirmed the decision of the Third Board of Appeal of EUIPO of 5 February 2025, and, therefore, the invalidity of design no. 000257001-0001 registered by Crocs.
UPC: managing costs through litigation funding and insurance
What happens when a smaller innovative company has a valuable patent, a credible infringement case, but cannot easily immobilise large amounts of cash or obtain a bank guarantee? Litigation funding and ATE insurance can help companies overcome the impasse.
Digital withdrawal rights: towards a new model of consumer protection
Legislative Decree No. 209 of 31 December 2025, implementing Directive (EU) 2023/2673, introduces significant changes to the rules governing distance contracts and the right of withdrawal in online transactions. In particular, for contracts concluded from 19 June 2026 onwards, traders will be required to incorporate a function dedicated to the exercise of the right of withdrawal into their digital interfaces.
The CJEU on Italian IP law: preliminary injunctions cannot become final without proceedings on the merits
The CJEU, following a referral from the Italian Court of Cassation, has clarified that Article 132(4) of the Italian IP Code is incompatible with EU law: a national provision cannot allow a preliminary injunction to remain in force if the right holder fails to bring proceedings on the merits within the prescribed time limit and the defendant applies for its revocation.
Green Claims: Italy implements the EU Directive and reshapes the rules of corporate environmental communication
With Legislative Decree No. 30 of 20 February 2026, in force as of 24 March 2026, Italy has implemented Directive (EU) 2024/825, also known as the “Green Claims Directive” (as we mentioned here), within the broader framework of the European Green Deal, aimed at strengthening consumer protection against unfair commercial practices related to environmental and sustainability issues.
The Unitary Patent and the Unified Patent Court: what is working, what is not, and what should come next
On 19 February 2026, I had the honour and privilege of being invited by the European Commission to discuss the UP and the UPC with some of Europe’s leading patent practitioners. This article sets out the reflections I shared on that occasion: where the system is already delivering, where the friction points are emerging in practice, and which technical adjustments would most effectively improve usability, predictability and legitimacy.
Milano - Cortina 2026: AGCM investigations into ambush marketing
The Milano - Cortina 2026 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games have come to an end, but the ambush marketing chapter is far from closed. In the weeks leading up to - and during - the event, the Italian Competition Authority (Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato – AGCM) turned its spotlight on promotional initiatives allegedly capable of creating an undue association with the Olympic event by operators that were not official sponsors. We previously discussed the phenomenon here and here.
The European Commission launches an investigation into Shein under the Digital Services Act
Today (17 February 2026), the European Commission launched formal proceedings against the well-known Chinese company Shein under the Digital Services Act (DSA), for its addictive design, the lack of transparency of recommender systems, as well as the sale of illegal products, including child sexual abuse material.